Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Message Board Top 25 Poll....starting 9/13

Collapse

Support The Site!

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Nov 1, 2026
    • Western Colorado moves ahead of CSUP due to relative strength of wins vs. other RMAC teams.
    • CSUP had trouble with BHS at home while Western thumped them in Spearfish.
    • Things could change if Colorado Mines pulls off a miracle win in Gunnison next week.
    • I'm now a believer in NW Mo after they took down Emporia in dominant fashion.
    • Northwood moves up because they are undefeated and beat Findlay but they have had a lot of close calls.
    • East Stroudsburg breaks into Top 10 beating Kutz.
    • Davenport moves up after close loss to Ferris, now they can fight it out with Tech.
    • I struggle with the southern teams. they are all bunched between 16 and 25, and frankly they could be in any order based on my ability to judge them. I was impressed that Valdosta handled West Alabama, but they dropped a position based on crowing out from teams above.
    Mineguy Ranking NPI Super Region Team Last week result Conference
    W
    Conference
    L
    Overall
    W
    Overall
    L
    1 70.007 3 Ferris St. Beat Davenport 23-14 5 0 9 0
    2 64.292 3 Minnesota St. Beat SW Minn St. 44-8 8 0 9 0
    3 67.031 4 Harding Beat Oklahoma Baptist 48-10 9 0 9 0
    4 69.179 1 Slippery Rock Beat Clarion 48-14 8 0 9 0
    5 61.447 4 Central Washington Beat Eastern New Mexico 49-19 6 0 6 2
    6 61.450 4 Western Colorado Beat SD Mines 37-6 7 0 9 0
    7 63.326 4 Northwest Missouri St. Beat Emporia 59-14 6 1 7 1
    8 64.918 4 CSU Pueblo Beat Black Hills State 38-31 7 0 9 0
    9 65.681 3 Northwood Beat Ashland 45-42 7 0 9 0
    10 63.794 1 East Stroudsburg Beat Kutztown 32-25 OT 7 1 8 1
    11 60.602 1 Kutztown Lost to East Stroudsburg 25-32 OT 7 1 8 1
    12 62.884 4 Emporia St. Lost to NW Mo 14-59 6 1 8 1
    13 60.196 3 Michigan Tech Beat Saginaw Valley 27-20 4 1 7 2
    14 59.951 3 Davenport Lost to Ferris State 14-23 5 1 8 1
    15 58.582 3 Minnesota Duluth Beat Jamestown 50-3 7 1 7 2
    16 60.072 2 Carson-Newman Beat Catawba 41-7 6 1 8 1
    17 56.697 4 Ouachita Baptist Defeated Southern Arkansas 52-21 7 2 7 2
    18 59.871 3 Findlay Beat Thomas More 49-0 6 1 8 1
    19 58.263 2 North Greenville Beat Erskine 45-10 5 1 8 1
    20 56.658 3 Augustana Beat Northern State 31-24 6 2 7 2
    21 54.503 2 UNC Pembroke Beat Chowan 38-21 4 1 7 2
    22 56.766 2 Valdosta St. Beat West Alabama 28-24 0 0 5 1
    23 60.965 2 Benedict Beat Savannah State 63-0 6 1 8 1
    24 61.834 2 Kentucky State Did not play 6 1 7 2
    25 61.116 2 Central State Beat Edward Waters 35-28 6 1 6 3
    26 58.704 1 Virginia Union Beat Lincoln (Pa) 62-0 7 0 8 1
    27 56.949 1 Johnson B. Smith Beat Virginia State 39-33 OT 6 1 7 2
    28 56.374 1 Virginia State Lost to Johnson C. Smith 33-39 OT 6 1 7 2
    29 57.418 3 Southeast Oklahoma Beat Henderson 35- 27 7 2 7 2
    30 54.466 1 Blooomsburg Beat West Chester 22-15 6 2 7 2
    Last edited by mineguy; 11-01-2026, 03:58 PM.

    Comment


      1. Ferris State
      2. Slippery Rock
      3. Harding
      4. Minnesota State
      5. CSU Pueblo
      6. Grand Valley State
      7. East Stroudsburg
      8. Northwest Missouri State
      9. Kutztown
      10. Findlay
      11. Valdosta State
      12. Western Colorado
      13. Virginia Union
      14. Michigan Tech
      15. Northwood
      16. Johnson C. Smith
      17. Davenport
      18. Central Missouri
      19. Central Washington
      20. Carson–Newman
      21. Colorado Mines
      22. Midwestern State
      23. Northeastern State
      24. Virginia State
      25. UNC Pembroke
      I'm hoping I can squeeze this one in just under the gun.
      “No matter how badly things get blown apart, we will always plant flowers again.”

      Comment


      • Originally posted by TheBigCat2192 View Post
        1. Ferris State
        2. Slippery Rock
        3. Harding
        4. Minnesota State
        5. CSU Pueblo
        6. Grand Valley State
        7. East Stroudsburg
        8. Northwest Missouri State
        9. Kutztown
        10. Findlay
        11. Valdosta State
        12. Western Colorado
        13. Virginia Union
        14. Michigan Tech
        15. Northwood
        16. Johnson C. Smith
        17. Davenport
        18. Central Missouri
        19. Central Washington
        20. Carson–Newman
        21. Colorado Mines
        22. Midwestern State
        23. Northeastern State
        24. Virginia State
        25. UNC Pembroke
        I'm hoping I can squeeze this one in just under the gun.
        No prob, I’ll get it counted up and posted shortly. Might be in the AM though.

        Comment


        • 🏈 MESSAGE BOARD TOP 25: WEEK 11 🏈

          14 ballots: two posted in the thread, 12 through the form.
          1. Ferris State (9-0) 350 🏆 14 of 14 first-place votes
          2. Harding (9-0) 332
          3. Minnesota State (9-0) 315
          4. CSU Pueblo (9-0) 305
          5. Slippery Rock (9-0) 283 🟢 ▲3
          6. Western Colorado (9-0) 277 🟢 ▲1
          7. Northwest Missouri State (7-1) 268 🟢 ▲2
          8. Central Washington (7-2) 235 🟢 ▲2
          9. Northwood (9-0) 232 🟢 ▲2
          10. Davenport (8-1) 202 🟢 ▲2
          11. Michigan Tech (7-2) 191 🟢 ▲2
          12. East Stroudsburg (8-1) 182 🟢 ▲7
          13. Emporia State (8-1) 173 🔴 ▼8
          14. Kutztown (8-1) 165 🔴 ▼8
          15. Findlay (8-1) 156 🔴 ▼1
          16. Minnesota Duluth (7-2) 146 🔴 ▼1
          17. Valdosta State (6-1) 119 🔴 ▼1
          18. Carson-Newman (8-1) 117 🔴 ▼1
          19. North Greenville (8-1) 83 🔴 ▼1
          20. Central Missouri (6-3) 66 🟢 ▲2
          21. Augustana (7-2) 64 🟢 ▲2
          22. Grand Valley State (5-3) 57 🔴 ▼2
          23. Ouachita Baptist (7-2) 37 🟢 ▲1
          24. Virginia Union (8-1) 35 🆕 was 31st
          25. Midwestern State (7-2) 27 🆕 was 34th

          🚪 Dropped out: Henderson State (was 21st), Virginia State (was 25th)

          📋 Also receiving votes: Benedict 25, Washburn 18, Colorado Mines 13, Johnson C. Smith 13, Southeastern Oklahoma State 12, Hillsdale 9, Wayne State (NE) 8, Kentucky State 6, UNC Pembroke 6, Northeastern State 5, Virginia State 4, Central State 4, Henderson State 4, Northern State 3, Shepherd 3.

          In all, 40 teams received at least one point.

          🔎 THE WEEK IN THE POLL

          👑 Ferris State sweeps all 14 first-place votes and holds an 18-point lead over Harding.

          🔥 Valdosta State is the most debated team in the poll, ranked anywhere from 10th to 25th. Kutztown ranges from 9th to 21st, and Central Washington from 5th to 19th.

          📉 Emporia State and Kutztown both slide 🔴 8 spots. East Stroudsburg makes the biggest climb, 🟢 up 7 to 12th.

          🌟 Two new faces this week: Virginia Union jumps in at 24th and Midwestern State at 25th.

          🤔 Midwestern State appears on only 5 of 14 ballots and still holds 25th. Those five know what they like.

          📊 The points fall off between 4/5, 7/8, 9/10.

          🔄 The southern slate was the hardest ballot in the room. Mineguy said it plain: the teams in that middle-to-bottom stretch could land in any order. That is how one team ends up in somebody's top ten and off the bottom of somebody else's.

          💬 Mineguy also said out loud what a lot of the ballots whispered: Northwest Missouri State took Emporia apart, and that made a believer out of Mineguy. The Bearcats' arrow on the page matches the mood of the thread.

          🧐 TheBigCat2192 slid a ballot in right at the gun. We will take it.

          🧮 The scoreboard and the ballots disagree in a few spots. Emporia State beat Michigan Tech 34-20. Seven of 14 ballots have the loser ranked higher: Gliac_fan10, Mk63NuclearBomb, ARtransplantedTWolf, Bisonfan from FLA, redwing, TheROCK, EastStroud13. East Stroudsburg beat Kutztown 32-25. Three of 14 ballots have the loser ranked higher: Mk63NuclearBomb, redwing, ftballfan. Emporia State beat Central Missouri 58-38, but TheROCK still has Central Missouri ahead. Michigan Tech beat Grand Valley State 41-35, but TheBigCat2192 still has Grand Valley State ahead.

          🕒 PROVISIONAL BALLOTS

          Not counted above, because there is no forum account under that name: Grantland Rice and Luke. They are on the page, and the Compare button there shows both polls side by side.
          If they had counted, ten teams would have moved:
          Harding 2nd → 3rd
          Minnesota State 3rd → 2nd
          Slippery Rock 5th → 7th
          Northwest Missouri State 7th → 5th
          East Stroudsburg 12th → 13th
          Emporia State 13th → 12th
          Kutztown 14th → 15th
          Findlay 15th → 14th
          Midwestern State 25th → 27th (out of the Top 25)
          Northeastern State 35th → 25th (into the Top 25)

          📏 FURTHEST FROM THE BOARD

          How many spots each ballot sits from everyone else, on average. The typical ballot is 2.4 away.
          TheBigCat2192 6.3: Johnson C. Smith 16th (everyone else: 36th)
          ftballfan 3.5: Wayne State (NE) 20th (everyone else: 39th)
          TheROCK 3.0: Hillsdale 18th (everyone else: 40th)

          ⏰ WEEK 12 VOTING

          Voting opens Sunday, 11/8 at 6:00 a.m. CT, after this weekend's games, and closes Wednesday, 11/11 at 9:30 p.m. CT. Ballots posted before Sunday morning won't count.

          Post your 25 here like always, or use the form: 👉 https://daqspickem.com/d2-poll

          👀 Every ballot is published as submitted. Click any team to see who ranked them where. As always if you notice anything off let me know.
          Last edited by reloadmvp; 11-05-2026, 12:21 PM. Reason: Added the provisional ballots section

          Comment


          • Originally posted by reloadmvp View Post

            No prob, I’ll get it counted up and posted shortly. Might be in the AM though.
            Much appreciated. I'm enjoying the community poll; my schedule just killed my ability to do the legwork ahead of time last week. Next week I expect to get my vote done in a timelier fashion.
            “No matter how badly things get blown apart, we will always plant flowers again.”

            Comment


            • I think it's time we boot Grantland Rice from the poll. Their rankings are just not serious: Northeastern State at #3? Central Oklahoma the highest MIAA team? IUP the only ranked PSAC team? Harding still down at 23rd? It makes no sense. They haven't even posted anything to defend themselves because they don't have an account on this board. I know the poll is just for fun but if the rankings don't at least make sense then what is the point?

              If anyone else also feels like they should be booted, sound off. Maybe I'm alone in this.

              Comment


              • Originally posted by EastStroud13 View Post
                I think it's time we boot Grantland Rice from the poll. Their rankings are just not serious: Northeastern State at #3? Central Oklahoma the highest MIAA team? IUP the only ranked PSAC team? Harding still down at 23rd? It makes no sense. They haven't even posted anything to defend themselves because they don't have an account on this board. I know the poll is just for fun but if the rankings don't at least make sense then what is the point?

                If anyone else also feels like they should be booted, sound off. Maybe I'm alone in this.
                I'm not sure if Grantland Rice is a troll or just doesn't know ball. His ballot obviously does not reflect anything a follower of D2 football would show. It this poll was for more than anything but our own entertainment I would agree with you. I would love it if he had an account here to at least defend his ballot.

                Comment


                • As a Harding supporter I have noticed his huge outlier on his voting towards Harding, thinking he just hated the Bisons and this was his way of showing his dislike. I was not aware he did not have an account here or that his voting was more scattered in the placement of teams. Thunder said it well that it could be a troll, doesn't know ball or just likes to "throw a monkey wrench into the works" or such.

                  Reload does a great job in posting this list and does state the various discrepancies that occur. Maybe he could include a new category to show discrepancies by the same individual and the frequency in the occurrence.

                  Comment


                  • i thought it would be fun to see what chat gpt came up with. here's the input:

                    "give me your d2 football top 25. you can't parrot other polls. research whatev & then rank them how you see fit, idc your criteria long as it's your poll that you defend. not pulling the d2 site poll or afca etc. so basically do it off available data points sans anyone's opinions."

                    & the chat gpt ballot:
                    1 Ferris State 9–0 Beat Michigan Tech, Central Washington and Davenport. Three wins over teams on this ballot.
                    2 Slippery Rock 9–0 Beat East Stroudsburg and Minnesota Duluth. Best pair of wins among the other unbeaten teams.
                    3 Harding 9–0 Beat Southeastern Oklahoma, Ouachita Baptist and Henderson State.
                    4 Minnesota State 9–0 Beat Wayne State (Neb.) and Northern State. The résumé runs deeper than the marquee wins.
                    5 East Stroudsburg 8–1 Beat Kutztown. Its only loss was to No. 2 Slippery Rock.
                    6 Colorado State Pueblo 9–0 Beat Central Missouri and Colorado Mines. The Central Missouri win separates Pueblo from Western Colorado.
                    7 Northwood 9–0 Beat 8–1 Findlay, plus Tiffin and Hillsdale.
                    8 Northwest Missouri State 7–1 Beat Emporia, Central Missouri and Washburn. The UCO loss keeps it out of the top tier.
                    9 Emporia State 8–1 Beat Michigan Tech and Central Missouri. Northwest is its only loss.
                    10 Western Colorado 9–0 Beat Colorado Mesa, Black Hills State and Chadron State. Still looking for a win over a team on this ballot.
                    11 Michigan Tech 7–2 Beat Midwestern State and Grand Valley. Lost only to Ferris and Emporia.
                    12 Kutztown 8–1 Beat Shepherd and Assumption. Its lone loss came against East Stroudsburg.
                    13 Carson–Newman 8–1 Beat Tiffin, Wingate and Lenoir–Rhyne. The Mars Hill loss holds it back.
                    14 Central Washington 7–2 Beat Midwestern State, UT Permian Basin and Western Oregon. Ferris is its only D2 loss.
                    15 Kentucky State 7–2 Beat Central State and Saginaw Valley. Lost to Edward Waters.
                    16 Central State (Ohio) 6–3 6–1 against D2, with wins over Edward Waters and Tuskegee. Kentucky State handed it the D2 loss.
                    17 Findlay 8–1 Beat Hillsdale, Walsh and Indianapolis. Its only loss came against unbeaten Northwood.
                    18 Benedict 8–1 Beat Edward Waters and Johnson C. Smith. Tuskegee handed it the loss.
                    19 Davenport 8–1 Beat Saginaw Valley, Truman and Indianapolis. Lost only to Ferris, but the wins are thinner than the record.
                    20 Minnesota Duluth 7–2 Beat Augustana, Northern State and Wayne State (Neb.). The Moorhead loss costs it.
                    21 North Greenville 8–1 Beat UNC Pembroke and West Alabama. The loss to Chowan is the drag.
                    22 Central Missouri 6–3 Beat Washburn, Delta State and UCO. All three losses came against teams in this top 10.
                    23 Edward Waters 6–3 The Kentucky State win gets it in. Losses to Central State and Benedict keep it below both.
                    24 Virginia Union 8–1 Beat Fayetteville State and Bowie State. The Lenoir–Rhyne loss leaves it near the cut.
                    25 Valdosta State 6–1 Beat Fayetteville State and West Alabama. The UNC Pembroke loss and shorter D2 résumé leave it on the bubble.
                    Go Bearcats!
                    M-I-Z-Z-O-U!

                    Comment


                    • i finally got around to putting some effort into compiling my own. it won't count for this week but here's something to throw tomatoes at:

                      1. ferris
                      2. minny st
                      3. pueblo
                      4. harding
                      5. western colo
                      6. central wash
                      7. nwms
                      8. emporia st
                      9. mich tech
                      10. davenport
                      11. slippery
                      12. northwood
                      13. findlay
                      14. valdosta st
                      15. duluth
                      16. carson newman
                      17. east stroud
                      18. kutz
                      19. north green
                      20. gvs
                      21. cm
                      22. auggy
                      23. northeastern st
                      24. ouchita
                      25. washburn
                      Go Bearcats!
                      M-I-Z-Z-O-U!

                      Comment


                      • Thanks for the feedback on this. Here's what I changed. This is just my first step, so we can adjust it if y'all don't like it.

                        Grantland Rice
                        I don't want to boot anyone over their football opinions. Personally I think that ballot is idiotic, but once you start removing ballots for being bad, it's hard to know where you stop. Everybody has biases, including me. So I made the rule about who's voting, not how they vote.

                        The new rule: official and provisional ballots
                        To count in the official poll, your name has to match an account on this forum. Ballots posted in this thread already do. A form ballot with no matching account is now provisional. It still gets published and nobody gets deleted, it just doesn't count toward the official numbers. We recheck those names against the forum every day during voting and right before the count, so if you make an account under that name, your ballot counts.

                        This changes Week 11
                        Grantland Rice and Luke don't have accounts under those names, so Week 11 is now 14 official ballots, and I edited my results post to match. The biggest changes: Harding moves up to 2nd and Minnesota State to 3rd, Slippery Rock moves to 5th and Northwest Missouri to 7th, and Midwestern State replaces Northeastern State at 25th. Luke, if you have an account under another name, let me know and I'll get you linked up. Grantland, make an account and come defend that ballot. We'd love to hear the case for Northeastern State at #3.

                        What's new on the site (https://daqspickem.com/d2-poll)
                        - A "provisional" button on the Poll tab shows the official poll, the poll with provisional ballots in, or a side-by-side of both, so you can see exactly what they would have changed.
                        - Bisonfan, this is your idea: each week now shows the three ballots furthest from everyone else. It's just information, not a callout. Sometimes that voter is just early. I can also add how often it happens if people want that.
                        - The results post will now list who wasn't counted and which teams they would have moved.
                        - The Submit Poll page now has a few short voting guidelines: rank what teams have done this season, check your own bias, have a reason if you put a loser ahead of the winner, and use your forum name.

                        Any feedback on this, one way or the other?

                        One last thing: who runs this forum?
                        Right now somebody could still type another person's forum name on the form. I reached out to Chuck but haven't heard back. Is Brandon back after his medical stuff? I haven't seen him in forever so I wasn't sure. If I could talk with whoever runs the site, I could connect directly to forum accounts, so you wouldn't even have to type your name. It would just know it's you, and that closes the hole for good. If you know who that is, tell them to get ahold of me. I can also remove that stupid debug info whoever left at the bottom of the page, hehehe.

                        While I'm plugging stuff: D2 pick'ems
                        I went ahead and set up pick'ems for D2: Top 25, conference based, and playoffs. Top 25 is live now and I've been testing it, and playoffs are the plan. It's here if anyone wants to use it: https://daqspickem.com/d2-pickem This isn't meant to step on anyone's toes. It's just a PIA to keep up with, and I know the MIAA has struggled to get the posts and results out. My plan is to set it up so it can link together, and the long-time folks who manage these and like doing it still can. It would just make it ten times easier for them.
                        Last edited by reloadmvp; 11-05-2026, 12:25 PM. Reason: Added the pick'em plug

                        Comment


                        • I think that's a good step. Ultimately what I think everyone wants is for the poll to represent the board so having official and provisional ballots feels like a good compromise. It's not simply being off from consensus that is the issue; TheBigCat also deviates from consensus but he is here defending his decisions, and the decisions have an internal logic to them.

                          Comment


                          • 1. Ferris State
                            2. Slippery Rock
                            3. Harding
                            4. Minnesota State
                            5. CSU Pueblo
                            6. East Stroudsburg
                            7. Northwest Missouri State
                            8. Kutztown
                            9. Findlay
                            10. Western Colorado
                            11. Valdosta State
                            12. Carson Newman
                            13. North Greenville
                            14. Northwood
                            15. Davenport
                            16. Virginia Union
                            17. Michigan Tech
                            18. Central Missouri
                            19. UNC- Pembroke
                            20. Central Washington
                            21. Benedict
                            22. Newberry
                            23. Kentucky State
                            24. Virginia State
                            25. Northeastern State

                            Comment


                            • Originally posted by EastStroud13 View Post
                              I think that's a good step. Ultimately what I think everyone wants is for the poll to represent the board so having official and provisional ballots feels like a good compromise. It's not simply being off from consensus that is the issue; TheBigCat also deviates from consensus but he is here defending his decisions, and the decisions have an internal logic to them.
                              I do think it’s ironic that I, someone who once said on here “I’ve never seen a CIAA team as good as their record”, ended up being the high guy on multiple CIAA teams by virtue of them doing the things I put stock in (losing rarely, mostly winning big when you do win, and consistently outgaining your opponents on a per play basis.)
                              “No matter how badly things get blown apart, we will always plant flowers again.”

                              Comment


                                1. Ferris State
                                2. Harding
                                3. Slippery Rock
                                4. Minnesota State
                                5. Michigan Tech
                                6. Valdosta State
                                7. Kutztown
                                8. CSU Pueblo
                                9. Findlay
                                10. Western Colorado
                                11. Northwest Missouri State
                                12. East Stroudsburg
                                13. Grand Valley State
                                14. Virginia Union
                                15. Central Washington
                                16. Midwestern State
                                17. Colorado Mines
                                18. Northwood
                                19. Saginaw Valley State
                                20. Northeastern State
                                21. Johnson C. Smith
                                22. Central Missouri
                                23. Truman
                                24. Davenport
                                25. Carson–Newman
                                Some real movement this week at both the top and the bottom.
                                “No matter how badly things get blown apart, we will always plant flowers again.”

                                Comment

                                Ad3

                                Collapse
                                Working...
                                X

                                Debug Information