AFCA All-Americans

[Fightingscot82]

I count 3 PSACers - surprised that some aren't listed but what do the coaches outside our region know?

[Matt Burglund]

I realize there's more to it than stats, but ...

	G	Com.	Att.	Yds	Int.	TD	Rush
Rogan Wells (1st team)	11	213	297	2,650	4	19	702
Brook Bolles (2nd team)	13	235	419	4,290	15	42	228
Roland Rivers	12	274	384	3,825	6	44	624
Tyson Bagent	12	343	483	4,349	13	36	37
Collin DiGalbo	12	229	355	3,193	10	30	571

[RockinTheSnackBar]

No team represented by two players

[Mad3 Boss]

I realize there's more to it than stats, but ...

	G	Com.	Att.	Yds	Int.	TD	Rush
Rogan Wells (1st team)	11	213	297	2,650	4	19	702
Brook Bolles (2nd team)	13	235	419	4,290	15	42	228
Roland Rivers	12	274	384	3,825	6	44	624
Tyson Bagent	12	343	483	4,349	13	36	37
Collin DiGalbo	12	229	355	3,193	10	30	571

no please tell me what all does it include to be first team because Roland Rivers should've won and if not the Rogan damn sure shouldn't have. too much mental with these choices. should be off current years stats

[jrshooter]

no please tell me what all does it include to be first team because Roland Rivers should've won and if not the Rogan damn sure shouldn't have. too much mental with these choices. should be off current years stats

I'm ridiculously impressed you saw all five play, rather than making that assessment off raw numbers.

Having seen both, I'd probably take Bagent over Rivers.

[Mad3 Boss]

I'm ridiculously impressed you saw all five play, rather than making that assessment off raw numbers.

Having seen both, I'd probably take Bagent over Rivers.

pretty sure youd take bagent over rivers especially after he put 416 4 pass td and 1 rush td on yall.

and yea I watched Roland beat bagent and digalbo and traveled to Valdosta and saw rogan play so yes be impressed.

[Matt Burglund]

I'm ridiculously impressed you saw all five play, rather than making that assessment off raw numbers.

Do you think the coaches who voted on this did?

[IUPbigINDIANS]

The SR1 poor reputation plays a factor.

[Mad3 Boss]

The SR1 poor reputation plays a factor.

I would've thought 5 PSAC teams in playoffs would've accounted for something

[Fightingscot82]

I would've thought 5 PSAC teams in playoffs would've accounted for something

The PSAC is viewed in D2 as the MAC is in FBS. The only reason we have teams finish top 10 is because there's a real playoff.

[Mad3 Boss]

The PSAC is viewed in D2 as the MAC is in FBS. The only reason we have teams finish top 10 is because there's a real playoff.

[Mad3 Boss]

I'm ridiculously impressed you saw all five play, rather than making that assessment off raw numbers.

Having seen both, I'd probably take Bagent over Rivers.

[EastStroud13]

The PSAC is viewed in D2 as the MAC is in FBS. The only reason we have teams finish top 10 is because there's a real playoff.

Naw. The AAC is a more apt comparison of perception. People see us as not the worst of the worst, but no shot at competing for titles. The MAC would be something like this year's NE-10.

[jrshooter]

That would probably be their mistake.

[iupgroundhog]

pretty sure youd take bagent over rivers especially after he put 416 4 pass td and 1 rush td on yall.

and yea I watched Roland beat bagent and digalbo and traveled to Valdosta and saw rogan play so yes be impressed.

Until his last game I thought DiGalbo was a better QB than Rivers. Rivers has better support than the other PSAC QB's IMO, a better line and better receivers. Statistically, at least for passing, Bagent does them all in. I think Rivers has untapped running ability. He beat IUP and Kutztown with his legs in the last minutes of the 4th quarter. If he needs to scramble he can beat most D2 teams.

It's hard to say who is best but it's difficult to understand the Valdosta guy being #1 with those stats.