Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Hey, League Office!

Collapse

Support The Site!

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • IUPbigINDIANS
    replied
    Just an FYI for all you gambling degenerates ...

    Week 1 for Pick 'Em will post tomorrow.

    Leave a comment:


  • IUPNation
    replied
    Originally posted by Fightingscot82 View Post

    No. The PAC are all smaller liberal arts colleges. Very few if any grad programs (with the obvious exceptions of Case Western and Waynesburg). Several are one bad year away from spiraling.

    Duquesne is fine. It's Villanova with many more doc programs, a law school and now med school. I would argue that Allegheny, Grove City (narrow worldview aside), and W&J are all good schools. Expand a bit and I'd throw in Juniata. The rest probably won't survive the next 10 years.
    Villanova has a law school. I thought the purchase of the Cabrini campus was for the law school but it’s not..?

    Leave a comment:


  • Fightingscot82
    replied
    Originally posted by IUPNation View Post


    Most of Those PAC schools are for trust fund babies who couldn’t get into actual really good schools. The only good private school in The Yinzerlands is Carnegie Mellon.

    Do any of them have a medical school?
    No. The PAC are all smaller liberal arts colleges. Very few if any grad programs (with the obvious exceptions of Case Western and Waynesburg). Several are one bad year away from spiraling.

    Duquesne is fine. It's Villanova with many more doc programs, a law school and now med school. I would argue that Allegheny, Grove City (narrow worldview aside), and W&J are all good schools. Expand a bit and I'd throw in Juniata. The rest probably won't survive the next 10 years.

    Leave a comment:


  • EastStroud13
    replied
    Originally posted by Tdobson View Post
    I always felt that the Presidents Athletic Conference schools were above the PSAC schools. Just my opinion.

    That could be because, when I was applying for colleges, I seen these schools price tag and said no way.

    But, I do wonder how those schools would fare against the PSAC schools in say football?

    I think Geneva, W and J, and Westminster would do ok, but the rest would probably not.

    I would also love to see IUP play Westminster or Geneva.
    Comparing across divisions is an imperfect science, but here are the 2025 combined PSAC/PAC rankings based on Massey ratings:
    1. Kutztown
    2. California
    3. IUP
    4. Slippery Rock
    5. East Stroudsburg
    6. Edinboro
    7. Shepherd
    8. Lock Haven
    9. Clarion
    10. Seton Hill
    11. West Chester
    12. Bloomsburg
    13. Washington & Jefferson
    14. Shippensburg
    15. Grove City
    16. Gannon
    17. Westminster
    18. Case Western
    19. Millersville
    20. Geneva
    21. Allegheny
    22. Waynesburg
    23. St. Vincent
    24. Hiram
    25. Thiel
    26. Bethany

    Leave a comment:


  • IUPNation
    replied
    Originally posted by IUPbigINDIANS View Post


    It's a strange vibe in the Yinzer half of the state. PSU obviously runs the show in the eyes of most. Pitt and Duquesne folks act like PASSHE schools are community colleges. Carnegie Mellon is so above our schools academically I don't think they even pay attention (or care).

    You'd be surprised by the Predsidents' Athletic Conference schools. They all have kind of a 'air' to them, also. In other words, they tend to think they are far above us academically. Because of this, many feel they couldn't compete athletically (with their perceived higher admission standards). They all also have a lot in common. They wouldn't really fit into the PSAC (much the way Seton Hill really doesn't).

    Most of Those PAC schools are for trust fund babies who couldn’t get into actual really good schools. The only good private school in The Yinzerlands is Carnegie Mellon.

    Do any of them have a medical school?

    Leave a comment:


  • IUPNation
    replied
    Originally posted by Fightingscot82 View Post

    We don't want St Vincent. That school is changing politically in a way that won't jive with public schools. Basically they're trying to be a Catholic version of Grove City. Any attempt at moving to D2 would be purely to try to align better with Duquesne.

    Vindication will come in a few years when either the NEC folds or due to lack of money Mercyhurst comes crawling back, but to be honest, I think they'd probably just go D3.
    The Home Office better tell The Lake Show to go get stuffed and say the GMAC is that way….

    Leave a comment:


  • Ship69
    replied
    Originally posted by Tdobson View Post
    I always felt that the Presidents Athletic Conference schools were above the PSAC schools. Just my opinion.

    That could be because, when I was applying for colleges, I seen these schools price tag and said no way.

    But, I do wonder how those schools would fare against the PSAC schools in say football?

    I think Geneva, W and J, and Westminster would do ok, but the rest would probably not.

    I would also love to see IUP play Westminster or Geneva.
    One of my grandsons had a short stay at Geneva some years back. (It was a short stay because he didn't seem to realize he actually had to show up for classes in addition to playing football.) Buy my wife and I did get out to Beaver Falls while he was there and watched Geneva play Frostburg. I believe it was Frostburg's last year in D3 and they were starting to load up for the switch to D2. They just absolutely murdered Geneva, 52-21, and then beat them 31-10 the next year at Frostburg in 2016, which I think was the last time they played. Geneva has played some good D3 ball over the years, but they'd likely be in big, big trouble against a good PSAC team.

    Leave a comment:


  • Chuck Bitner
    replied
    I spoke with the SID at Lackawanna on Monday. I was looking for any info on their program so Cary and I can prepare for the season preview show. He shared a lot of great info with me and indicated they were not included in the PSAC digital media day simply because they are not officially a member yet. They won't be until they are accepted into the D2 provisional membership process. I already knew that, but I also felt it would be appropriate to include the Lackawanna program in some way, since they are playing a full PSAC schedule. I guess the league didn't feel they had a good way to do it without creating more confusion. At any rate, Lackawanna will be included when we do the PSAC preview show (likely next week).

    Leave a comment:


  • IUPbigINDIANS
    replied
    Originally posted by Tdobson View Post
    I always felt that the Presidents Athletic Conference schools were above the PSAC schools. Just my opinion.

    That could be because, when I was applying for colleges, I seen these schools price tag and said no way.

    But, I do wonder how those schools would fare against the PSAC schools in say football?

    I think Geneva, W and J, and Westminster would do ok, but the rest would probably not.

    I would also love to see IUP play Westminster or Geneva.


    Our top programs would absolutely murder them.

    Our worst teams would likely still beat them up.


    Now, top level D3 teams ... different story. But, nobody in the PAC is beating a good PSAC team.

    Different sport but we routinely play some PSAC vs PAC non-conference games in basketball. Slaughters.

    Leave a comment:


  • Tdobson
    replied
    I always felt that the Presidents Athletic Conference schools were above the PSAC schools. Just my opinion.

    That could be because, when I was applying for colleges, I seen these schools price tag and said no way.

    But, I do wonder how those schools would fare against the PSAC schools in say football?

    I think Geneva, W and J, and Westminster would do ok, but the rest would probably not.

    I would also love to see IUP play Westminster or Geneva.

    Leave a comment:


  • IUPbigINDIANS
    replied
    Originally posted by ESU Warrior View Post

    St Vincent didn’t even apply for membership. The only school they did was Lack. Can’t accept st Vincent if they don’t fill out an application.

    It's a strange vibe in the Yinzer half of the state. PSU obviously runs the show in the eyes of most. Pitt and Duquesne folks act like PASSHE schools are community colleges. Carnegie Mellon is so above our schools academically I don't think they even pay attention (or care).

    You'd be surprised by the Predsidents' Athletic Conference schools. They all have kind of a 'air' to them, also. In other words, they tend to think they are far above us academically. Because of this, many feel they couldn't compete athletically (with their perceived higher admission standards). They all also have a lot in common. They wouldn't really fit into the PSAC (much the way Seton Hill really doesn't).

    Leave a comment:


  • gman16506
    replied
    Originally posted by Fightingscot82 View Post

    We don't want St Vincent. That school is changing politically in a way that won't jive with public schools. Basically they're trying to be a Catholic version of Grove City. Any attempt at moving to D2 would be purely to try to align better with Duquesne.

    Vindication will come in a few years when either the NEC folds or due to lack of money Mercyhurst comes crawling back, but to be honest, I think they'd probably just go D3.
    Still do not understand the move to D-1 by the Hurst. Certainly, they had projections that there would be financial stress in the near future? If not, then what does that say about their Board of Directors or perhaps their financial consultants who did the analytical work? Hope it wasn't the school's academic business division as that would say a lot.

    Leave a comment:


  • Fightingscot82
    replied
    Originally posted by ESU Warrior View Post

    St Vincent didn’t even apply for membership. The only school they did was Lack. Can’t accept st Vincent if they don’t fill out an application.
    We don't want St Vincent. That school is changing politically in a way that won't jive with public schools. Basically they're trying to be a Catholic version of Grove City. Any attempt at moving to D2 would be purely to try to align better with Duquesne.

    Vindication will come in a few years when either the NEC folds or due to lack of money Mercyhurst comes crawling back, but to be honest, I think they'd probably just go D3.

    Leave a comment:


  • ESU Warrior
    replied
    Originally posted by Sec10-A-14 View Post
    "I’ve seen the blueprint, and I have a picture of it, but I don’t want to post it for confidentiality issues. Once completed, I do think it will be one of the better stadiums (no track around it!), to watch a game and they will also be the only school (to my knowledge) with their own indoor football bubble. Fieldhouse will be 3 stories, and it looks like the setup will be similar to Shepherd’s, where Shep has theirs behind the end zone with locker rooms on each side (although this looks much larger)"

    ES U Warrier,

    Gannon

    Edinboro, while not turf there is plenty of room for A FB team to practice in the dome.

    I appreciate the feedback. I forgot about Gannon. I remember when Edinboro was building theirs, and I know it was years ago, but I thought it was to small for the football team to use.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ship69
    replied
    Originally posted by EastStroud13 View Post
    The PSAC was desperate for a team to fill schedules rather than actually make the conference stronger, so they found a team equally desperate to move up even though they weren't actually prepared to do so. Lackawanna will get blown out every week in embarrassing fashion and now the door is closed on the PSAC inviting a legitimate program in the future like Frostburg.

    Maybe I'll be wrong and Lackawanna will be competitive. I don't think I will be.
    You might be right about Lackawanna. It's a big step up. But then I look at a Shippensburg team that has a roster consisting half of freshmen with no seniors. With the ravages of the portal, are some of these teams really all that much farther along than Lackawanna? We're about to find out.

    Leave a comment:

Ad3

Collapse
Working...
X

Debug Information