I've done something like this for D2 football. Here is a men's and women's basketball 5 year program rankings based off playoff success and win %
Men's
Women's
Men's
School | Conference | TOTAL | School | Conference | TOTAL | School | Conference | TOTAL | School | Conference | TOTAL | |||||||
1 | West Liberty | MEC | 160 | 1 | Northwest Missouri State | MIAA | 744 | 1 | St. Anselm | NE10 | 61 | 1 | Ferris State | GLIAC | 256 | |||
2 | Indiana (PA) | PSAC | 73 | 2 | Northern State | NSIC | 131 | 2 | Bentley | NE10 | 37 | 2 | UMSL | GLVC | 38 | |||
3 | Mercyhurst | PSAC | 39 | 3 | Minnesota-Duluth | NSIC | 27 | 3 | New Haven | NE10 | 34 | 3 | Hillsdale | GMAC | 36 | |||
4 | East Stroudsburg | PSAC | 28 | 4 | Southern Nazarene | GAC | 17 | 4 | St. Thomas Aquinas | ECC | 33 | 4 | Truman | GLVC | 26 | |||
5 | Shippensburg | PSAC | 12 | 5 | Missouri Southern | MIAA | 13 | 5 | Daemen | ECC | 25 | 5 | Findlay | GMAC | 16 | |||
6 | California (PA) | PSAC | 11 | 6 | Minnesota State | NSIC | 12 | 6 | Bloomfield | CACC | 15 | 6 | McKendree | GLVC | 11 | |||
7 | Virginia State | CIAA | 9 | 7 | Augustana (SD) | NSIC | 11 | 7 | Dominican (NY) | CACC | 8 | 7 | Michigan Tech | GLIAC | 9 | |||
8 | Fairmont State | MEC | 5 | 8 | Washburn | MIAA | 10 | 8 | Caldwell | CACC | 8 | 8 | Ashland | GMAC | 6 |
School | Conference | TOTAL | School | Conference | TOTAL | School | Conference | TOTAL | School | Conference | TOTAL | |||||||
1 | Nova Southeastern | SSC | 300 | 1 | West Texas A&M | LSC | 216 | 1 | Augusta | PBC | 136 | 1 | Point Loma Nazarene | PWC | 135 | |||
2 | Barry | SSC | 27 | 2 | Black Hills State | RMAC | 114 | 2 | Lincoln Memorial | SAC | 96 | 2 | Cal State San Bernardino | CCAA | 62 | |||
3 | Alabama-Huntsville | GSC | 25 | 3 | Colorado Mines | RMAC | 27 | 3 | Flagler | PBC | 55 | 3 | Chico State | CCAA | 27 | |||
4 | Embry-Riddle (FL) | SSC | 13 | 4 | Lubbock Christian | LSC | 17 | 4 | USC Aiken | PBC | 15 | 4 | St. Martin's | GNAC | 16 | |||
5 | Lynn | SSC | 11 | 5 | Colorado Mesa | RMAC | 14 | 5 | Emmanuel (GA) | CC | 13 | 5 | Western Oregon | GNAC | 12 | |||
6 | Eckerd | SSC | 11 | 6 | St. Edward's | LSC | 12 | 6 | UNC Pembroke | CC | 11 | 6 | Northwest Nazarene | GNAC | 12 | |||
7 | Florida Southern | SSC | 9 | 7 | UTPB | LSC | 11 | 7 | Catawba | SAC | 6 | 7 | Alaska | GNAC | 11 | |||
8 | West Alabama | GSC | 9 | 8 | Dallas Baptist | LSC | 8 | 8 | Clayton State | PBC | 4 | 8 | Azusa Pacific | PWC | 10 |
School | Conference | TOTAL | School | Conference | TOTAL | School | Conference | TOTAL | School | Conference | TOTAL | |||||||
1 | Glenville State | MEC | 314 | 1 | Central Missouri | MIAA | 310 | 1 | Daemen | ECC | 36 | 1 | Ashland | GMAC | 384 | |||
2 | Indiana (PA) | PSAC | 116 | 2 | Southwestern Oklahoma State | GAC | 131 | 2 | St. Anselm | NE10 | 27 | 2 | Drury | GLVC | 194 | |||
3 | Charleston (WV) | MEC | 39 | 3 | Minnesota-Duluth | NSIC | 127 | 3 | Pace | NE10 | 26 | 3 | Grand Valley State | GLIAC | 85 | |||
4 | California (PA) | PSAC | 18 | 4 | Fort Hays State | MIAA | 28 | 4 | Assumption | NE10 | 26 | 4 | Walsh | GMAC | 17 | |||
5 | Bowie State | CIAA | 13 | 5 | Missouri Western | MIAA | 26 | 5 | Jefferson | CACC | 18 | 5 | Tiffin | GMAC | 11 | |||
6 | West Chester | PSAC | 12 | 6 | Nebraska-Kearney | MIAA | 13 | 6 | Roberts Wesleyan | ECC | 11 | 6 | Lewis | GLVC | 10 | |||
7 | Virginia Union | CIAA | 6 | 7 | Augustana (SD) | NSIC | 12 | 7 | Bentley | NE10 | 10 | 7 | Truman | GLVC | 5 | |||
8 | Edinboro | PSAC | 5 | 8 | Missouri Southern | MIAA | 12 | 8 | St. Thomas Aquinas | ECC | 6 | 8 | Northern Michigan | GLIAC | 4 |
School | Conference | TOTAL | School | Conference | TOTAL | School | Conference | TOTAL | School | Conference | TOTAL | |||||||
1 | Union (TN) | GSC | 78 | 1 | Lubbock Christian | LSC | 540 | 1 | North Georgia | PBC | 104 | 1 | Western Washington | GNAC | 122 | |||
2 | Valdosta State | GSC | 42 | 2 | West Texas A&M | LSC | 43 | 2 | Lander | PBC | 81 | 2 | Azusa Pacific | PWC | 62 | |||
3 | Tampa | SSC | 32 | 3 | UT Tyler | LSC | 26 | 3 | Catawba | SAC | 62 | 3 | MSU Billings | GNAC | 30 | |||
4 | Nova Southeastern | SSC | 27 | 4 | Angelo State | LSC | 20 | 4 | Carson-Newman | SAC | 33 | 4 | Cal State Dominguez Hills | CCAA | 26 | |||
5 | Eckerd | SSC | 18 | 5 | Westminster (UT) | RMAC | 13 | 5 | Belmont Abbey | CC | 24 | 5 | Alaska-Ancorage | GNAC | 24 | |||
6 | Lee | GSC | 15 | 6 | Colorado Mesa | RMAC | 6 | 6 | Georgia Southwestern | PBC | 15 | 6 | Cal State San Marcos | CCAA | 13 | |||
7 | Florida Southern | SSC | 14 | 7 | Black Hills State | RMAC | 6 | 7 | Wingate | SAC | 13 | 7 | Cal State East Bay | CCAA | 11 | |||
8 | Embry-Riddle (FL) | SSC | 4 | 8 | Metro State | RMAC | 5 | 8 | Barton | CC | 11 | 8 | Northwest Nazarene | GNAC | 7 |