It's an NCAA thing (not unique to the PSAC). In D1 the same thing is happening. The mid-majors are essentially turning in to a feeder system. Locally, Robert Morris has been gutted several times.
Are individual leagues, at any level, allowed to restrict Intra-conference transfers in any way ?
Maybe I misstated my question. If the schools that are losing players push to change the rules to discourage transfers, say a one season suspension, would the better schools put up resistance ?
It's an NCAA thing (not unique to the PSAC). In D1 the same thing is happening. The mid-majors are essentially turning in to a feeder system. Locally, Robert Morris has been gutted several times.
The closest game IUP has had against Clarion in the past decade came on Wednesday night, Feb. 10, 2016.
IUP won, 69-68, after trailing by 8 points at halftime.
Clarion's football and wrestling teams all sat court-side and made it a very tough environment. They announced a crowd of 701 that night but it was well over 1,300. Clarion didn't scan tickets for students. If anybody can remember the old days inside Tippin, it can be one of the loudest gyms around when crowded. It has extremely low ceilings and terrible acoustics.
Add to it, Dante Lombardi and Daddy Ugbede were in serious foul trouble much of the game. Believe it or not (sarcasm) Joe had a short bench to start so having two guys out really hurt. Making matters worse, Jacobo Diaz dressed but due to injury hobbled through just 11 unproductive minutes before he was sat down for the night. Walk-on C.J. Rudisill had to take his place. Recall, Devon Cottrell was also out.
The Golden Eagles hit some miraculous shots in the second half. In fact, Clarion missed a FT with 2 seconds left that would have tied the game. Had the game gone to OT, Joe may have played 4 guys -- by default. On the missed FT, IUP's Tevin Hanner rebounded it and was instantly fouled. No time ran. Hanner than missed both FTs, giving Clarion one more shot. A long heave just missed -- and, I mean, just missed.
On the night, IUP shot a terrible 19-30 from the FT line. Brandon Norfleet led all scorers with 22 points. IUP trailed almost the whole way up until the final minutes.
The part of the trip I'll never forget -- aside from the thrilling ending -- was the ride home. All day the forecast for Clarion was calling for just flurries. As anybody who spends time up in the mountains near Clarion knows, that can change real quick. And, naturally, it did. I remember walking out of Tippin Gym and thinking WTF. It was snowing. Hard. Not a good place to be in a fluke snow storm. My ride home that night took well over 3 hours -- and would normally take just over 60 minutes.
Maybe I misstated my question. If the schools that are losing players push to change the rules to discourage transfers, say a one season suspension, would the better schools put up resistance ?
Gary Edwards wrote a great column last week sharing his thoughts on the 'transfer portal' and how it's become all the rage in college basketball. This past summer his best returning player asked to be put in the portal ... 'to test the D1 waters'. The day before fall classes started he left -- leaving Edwards high and dry.
My personal opinion is the portal is going to ruin D2 basketball -- in particular for the average and weak programs. It's too easy to leave now. If the big schools pass you ... go to a Clarion or Seton Hill for a year and then bolt.
My guess is there will be a lot of the better players in the PSAC who currently reside on lesser teams looking for new homes in the very near future (as in next week). Seton Hill could get gutted. They have a couple nice freshmen. The big guy from Ligonier Valley would be attractive to most schools. The guard from the DMV. Same with Clarion.
I think this is going to make the poor teams a feeder system for the wealthy -- almost a developmental league within the league.
Would those stronger teams have the clout to kill any thoughts of reinstituting the old rules limiting transferring within the conference ?
Leave a comment: