Should Jamestown be accepted into the NSIC?

[SW_Mustang]

Was just a quick comment in the moment. I knew Morningside would immediately be commented on by someone here that they'll never leave NAIA because they're comfortable. So went with the 2nd school of the cuff

That's fair, and I agree with Morningside.

[CollegeFBGuy]

C'mon now. You can't lump SDSU with Alabama. They've built their programs to different rules. FCS and FBS are different football divisions sharing only the "D1" moniker. That's why SDSU and Michigan are both D1 national champions in football.

Dropping the 1AA for the FCS label has confused many casual football fans. I hear so much confusion on the differences in FBS vs FCS and how they’re all D1.

[zimmy21]

Dropping the 1AA for the FCS label has confused many casual football fans. I hear so much confusion on the differences in FBS vs FCS and how they’re all D1.

That distinction never changed how the casuals understood. Let's not kid ourselves

[zimmy21]

NDSU occupied a space where they could have their cake and eat it too. They were beating semi-quality FBS teams and getting College Gameday, but had the safety net of an FCS trophy to contend for. To sum up how insufferable the fanbase was - people were unironically making signs that said "We Want Bama." I even heard once that there were calls to join the Big10 but I can't confirm it.

SDSU was the little brother, and now they are in control of the bracket. It's made that fanbase almost as equally as insufferable. I've talked to some alumni who are frankly kind of embarrassed by it because they didn't want to stoop to the level NDSU is on. It's also bled into the other sports, which are not quality programs even by NSIC standards. One Jacks fan told me that SMSU (and the NSIC) eats their lunch on volleyball recruiting, for example.

IMO - if a school wants to be DI, let them be DI and deal with all that comes with it. The more contingencies we put in for the lesser DIs, the worse the overall product becomes. I also truly don't believe Augustana, MSU, GVSU, NWMSU, etc. - have anything to add to D1 by any tangible measurement, just as I believe SDSU and NDSU don't add anything to DI, especially from a top down perspective.

I don't hate SDSU - they were very nice by letting me prepare for grad school with them. A couple of guys on the team gave me some great insight for a class project I did and I'm grateful for it. The games can be really fun. I'm just tired of the lunacy. I chose to be a fan on my own terms - which included secretly rooting for Augie last night despite half of my team sitting in my section lol.

That's a pretty bleak way of looking at College athletics, I wonder why you watch/care about anything college then that isn't SEC Football/Baseball/NCHC Hockey/Big XII basketball

[vikingfaithful]

If NDSU and SDSU could find a way to add 21, more football scholarships and move to FBS. Where they would fail vs. the big boys is in NIL money. Read Ohio State handed out 20 million dollars to their football team alone. They would be lost in the myriad of mid majors like TN. Martin or N. Alabama.

[SW_Mustang]

That's a pretty bleak way of looking at College athletics, I wonder why you watch/care about anything college then that isn't SEC Football/Baseball/NCHC Hockey/Big XII basketball

It's odd that you care about my DI viewing habits, but that is a fairly accurate description - the only two exceptions being my one in-person SDSU game a year (only if I've heard of the opponent before), and Mavs hockey (the team that did this funny thing called going to the national championship recently? The Summit League should try it sometime).

By all means, if the PFL is what you fancy - don't let the fact that it's terrible football distract you from enjoying it. You are right about one thing though, you don't follow SDSU/NDSU - but hey, it's cute they "Want 'Bama," right?

I'm just tired of all the pandering to the 150 DI programs that aren't worth anything to DI. At least most DII/DIII schools know their place.

[SW_Mustang]

Anyway - enough arguing over whether USC-Upstate is a god tier basketball program worth watching. I originally came here to say that Dakota State is 3-0, having blanked Jamestown 16-6 during HoCo, before actually having to discuss how fascinating Drake's football program is.

Football vs Jamestown (N.D.) on 9/14/2024 - Box Score - Dakota State University (dsuathletics.com)

Too bad it's too late to get them in instead.

[Stanger86]

I'm just tired of all the pandering to the 150 DI programs that aren't worth anything to DI. At least most DII/DIII schools know their place.

Who panders?

[SW_Mustang]

Who panders?

The people with decision making ability who looked at Mercyhurst and said "That's the epitome of athletic competition - let's allow them to suck resources while they don't compete" and the other 149 programs exactly like them.

Watching pro sports with some of the people in this thread sounds like a nightmare. "Yeah, the Sioux Falls Storm should move up - that's exactly what the NFL needs."

I could provide thoughts on the NCAA tournament - but I have a feeling that won't go over so well. Be wild if the NBA worked like that though.

[SW_Mustang]

I guess it doesn't really matter. Let's all just enjoy what we want to watch.

[Purple Mav Man]

Watching pro sports with some of the people in this thread sounds like a nightmare. "Yeah, the Sioux Falls Storm should move up - that's exactly what the NFL needs."

I could provide thoughts on the NCAA tournament - but I have a feeling that won't go over so well. Be wild if the NBA worked like that though.

You’re confusing affiliate teams with different divisions in order to make a dramatic point. And also different leagues (NCAA is still one entity for all divisions).

And, in a way, that IS how the NBA works. Except it’s not full teams being promoted/moving up. It’s the individual players from said affiliate teams.

That said, I am also of the belief that D1 is watered down and the dream is better than the reality (in more cases than not).

[zimmy21]

The people with decision making ability who looked at Mercyhurst and said "That's the epitome of athletic competition - let's allow them to suck resources while they don't compete" and the other 149 programs exactly like them.

Nobody claimed Mercyhurst was a powerhouse, but just like some people's reasoning for Jamestown to be added into the NSIC, it's a number game for memberships.

I don't understand the thought process of caring for a school that "Brings Nothing" to the NCAA in SMSU? Why would you bother with a school that has no meaningful opportunity for a National Championship?

[debergfan]

Dropping the 1AA for the FCS label has confused many casual football fans. I hear so much confusion on the differences in FBS vs FCS and how they’re all D1.

wait until that comes to Division 2

[Tech Boys]

Congratulations on hitting 50 pages. Don't know what was being talked about when someone was saying this thread hit 100 pages.









Yes I am aware of the different settings. I see 40 posts per page, those with 10 posts per page are past 100.

[Stanger86]

I don't understand the thought process of caring for a school that "Brings Nothing" to the NCAA in SMSU? Why would you bother with a school that has no meaningful opportunity for a National Championship?

Makes sense that a Mavericks fan wouldn't know that volleyball exists. But at the same time, I always appreciate a good troll job.

Just like all NCAA sports matter, so do all NCAA institutions.