Division II Playoffs - Round One Recap

November 22nd, 2026 6:00am

Division II Playoffs - Round One Recap

By Chuck Bitner, D2Football.com

The first round of the Division II playoff is complete. We started the weekend with 32 teams hoping to advance to round two and now we’re left with just 16. From a fan’s perspective, it wasn’t the best round we’ve ever had, but it sure started off in the best way possible. 

Defending national champion Ferris State began the day with FOX Sports’ Big Noon Kickoff broadcasting live on-campus, from just outside Top Taggart Field. The Bulldog fans turned out in the huge numbers and created the atmosphere the networks hope for when they visit any destination. It looked spectacular on television and the FOX crew seemed genuinely excited to be there and pleased with how the event played out. All of us who advocate for Division II football and Division II athletes have longed for the day when the national television pregame shows finally realize there is an opportunity to do something special by visiting a D2 school. Ferris State was a deserving host and did all the right things to prove this can be successful and should be considered more frequently. 

As for the action on the field, the day had its moments. The first kickoff of the afternoon delivered the most drama and perhaps most notable result. The “late” game, which we only got thanks to having a host in the Pacific time zone, was also among the few that came down to the final play. In between, things mostly went as expected. Although, it is worth noting a handful of the games were much more competitive than the final scores may indicate. There were two themes to the day - rushing stats and defenses creating short fields for an opportunistic offense.  Let’s take a look at how the day went. We'll go in reverse order, starting in Super Region Four. SR4 was the only region to see all four seeded teams advance. 

Super Region Four

No. 1 CSU Pueblo 34, Midwestern State 10

No. 1 CSU Pueblo trailed for most of the second quarter against unseeded Midwestern State. The Thunderwolves reclaimed the lead just seconds before the halftime break with a 6-play, 88-yard scoring drive. That started a run of 27 unanswered points to close the game. After allowing 10 points from Midwestern State’s first two drives, the Pack defense was in control the rest of the way. The Mustangs netted just 83 yards of total offense in the second half and three of their six drives went backward. The Pack defense ended the day with seven sacks. Jaylon Booth led the way with 3.5 tackles for loss and 2.5 sacks while AJ Jordan added two sacks and a forced fumble.  On the offensive side, Navi Bruson threw four touchdown passes, two of them to AJ Merrida. It was a good day for the Thundwerwolves, but it wasn’t all pretty. The Pack turned the ball over three times and went just 1 for 11 on third down. 

No. 2 Harding 59, Washburn 31

This was a 37-31 game at the end of the third quarter but Harding dominated the final period with a 21-0 run. With a slim six-point lead, the Bisons chewed up more than eight minutes as the fourth period began, executing a 15-play, 91-yard scoring drive. That built the lead to 13 points and put all the pressure on Washburn to respond. The Ichabods went 3-and-out on the next drive and Harding made them pay. The Bisons put the game out of reach with 50-yard scoring drive and then added one more after a turnover on downs deep in Washburn territory. It wa a commendable performance most of the way for Washburn and they did have a chance to win the game in the fourth quarter. The Ichabods held up decently to the dive play. Harding’s Andrew Miller had 125 yards, but it took 28 carries to get there. The Bisons found plenty of space elsewhere though. All told, Harding rolled up 575 total yards, with 535 on the ground. Three different players topped the 100 yard mark for Harding with Jeff Regan’s 175 leading all ball carriers. 

No. 3 Northwest Missouri State 45, Ouachita Baptist 14

A slim 17-14 halftime lead turned into a commanding 45-14 Bearcat victory as Northwest pulled away from visiting Ouachita Baptist with 28 unanswered second half points. A punishing run game posted 398 yards on the ground. Their total output of 592 yards was a playoff record for the program and that’s saying something considering it was the Bearcats’ 54th playoff victory. Quincy Torry averaged 8.3 yards per carry, putting up 132 for the day. QB Zechariah Owens also went over 100 yards with 112 and two touchdowns. Defensivelyly, Eric Smith, III had a pair of sacks and forced two fumbles. Ouachita had two impressive scoring drives early in the day (72 and 89 yards). After that, their longest drive went just 34 yards and the Tigers punted on six straight possessions. 

No. 4 Central Washington 24, Western Colorado 17

For a while, it looked like Central Washington might be the only seeded team to fall in the first round of the SR4 bracket. This was one was headed towards being the lowest scoring game of the day, but a pair of Wildcat scores in the third turned things around. Ryder Bumgarner then put the game out of reach with a 50-yard burst to build the lead to 14-points. That was the last of three straight touchdowns for Central Washington. Western Colorado did finally answer, cutting the deficit back to one score. The Mountaineers had 10 minutes to complete the comeback, and reached CWU territory in the game’s final seconds, but a fourth down pass was intercepted, ending the threat. Bumgarner was the main weapon for the Wildcats, rushing for 151 yards and two touchdowns. 

Super Region Four Second Round Matchups

No. 4 Central Washigton at No. 1 CSU Pueblo

No. 3 Northwest Missouri State at No. 2 Harding

Super Region Three

No. 1 Ferris State 45, Truman State 14

Things started a little slowly for Ferris State and frankly, I didn’t find that surprising. The excitement of having FOX on campus was a distraction on a level we may have never seen before, and it started nearly a full week before the game. That said, once the Bulldogs settled in, they scored three times in the second quarter to  begin pulling away. To their credit, Truman State scored their only touchdown of the day  at the start of the third quarter. That gave them life and reasons to believe they could rally. But Ferris State answered on the next drive and Truman didn’t have enough to keep pace. Wyatt Bower played only sparingly for Ferris State. Chase Carter took the bulk of the snaps and Marcel Jones was in the mix as well. 

Grand Valley State 27, No. 2 Northwood 16

Grand Valley State played like a team with a new lease on life, knocking out No. 2 seed and G-MAC Champion Northwood. The game was tied for a couple of stretches in the first half and was knotted at 10 at the break. But the Lakers never trailed and used a 17-0 run in the second half to build a lead that Northwood could not chip away at. Time of possession was a factor with Grand Valley holding possession for 39:01. The Laker defense frustrated Northwood all day. They limited the Timberwolves to just one third down conversion in ten tries and intercepted Ethan Hamby twice. 

No. 3 Michigan Tech 35, Minnesota State 21

Michigan Tech trailed 14-6 at halftime to visiting Minnesota State, but the Huskies erupted for 22 third quarter points (part of a 29-0 run) to put away the Mavs. The QB run game was a challenge all day for an MSU defense that has struggled down the stretch. Alex Bueno rushed for 94 yards and a pair of TDs, while also passing for 238 yards. Abram Larner hauled in six catches for 121 yards and two TD. Jaiden Bolden had both of Michigan Tech’s interceptions. For the Mavs, it was a hard to get the passing game going, with both QBs combining for just 153 yards. Sam Backer had just two carries before leaving the game with an injury.  

No. 4 Findlay 23, Augustana 20 (OT)

Findlay used an aggressive defensive front to frustrate Augustana’s offense and force a ton of mistakes from the normally productive Vikings. The Oilers were outgained by nearly 140 yards but they were opportunistic and made Augie pay for mistakes. Augustana’s standout quarterback Gunnar Hensley finished with 342 yards, but was also picked off twice and sacked three times but the Oilers’ defense. The offense wasn’t superb for Findlay, but they made big plays in big moments. The run game didn’t do much, but they had some success throwing the ball and on a day the defense wasn’t breaking, it was enough to finish the job. Both teams were penalized 10 times but it felt like Augustana’s infractions hurt them more than Findlay’s. 

Super Region Three Second Round Matchups

No. 4 Findlay at No. 1 Ferris State

Grand Valley State at No. 3 Michigan Tech

 

Super Region Two 

Newberry 38, No. 1 Benedict 3

I wasn’t expecting a great day for the three seeded SIAC teams but I thought Benedict had a chance to win this part of the bracket. Overall, it was a bitterly disappointing day for the Tigers. This was the third time in five years they’ve held the number one seed, but lost their first playoff game - all at home. Neither offense had much going in this game, which was played in a steady (and at times heavy) rain. But Newberry was opportunistic and took advantage of Benedict mistakes. Turnovers helped set up a short field for Newberry on multiple occasions. The Wolves had three scoring drives that were under 30 yards. Conditions were unideal, but Benedict was just 5-for-21 throwing the ball and tossed three interceptions.

No. 2 Valdosta State 56, Edward Waters 26

Valdosta State was the only seeded team to advance in the SR2 bracket. With heavy clouds parked over the stadium, the entire game was played in dark, dreary and rainy conditions. The Blazers decided they would simply rely on the ground game to see them through it, and it worked. Valdosta State gashed the Edward Waters defense for 482 rushing yards. Matt Wilson  led the day with 238 yards and a touchdown. His yardage set a new program record for rushing in a playoff game. The Blazers attempted just one pass all day. Defensively, VSU sacked Edward Waters QB Tavion Faulk six times and came away with three interceptions. 

UNC Pembroke 42, No. 3 Central State 23

UNC Pembroked earned the program’s first playoff win since 2016 and first ever at home. Central State was the seeded team but did not submit a hosting bid, thus, the game was played at UNCP’s home field. This was a close game…until the fourth quarter. The Braves held a 14-13 lead at the half and a five point lead after three quarters. They were able to build a quick lead in the fourth thanks to the defense setting up short fields. A pair of interceptions set up the Pembroke offense in plus territory and they took advantage of both turnovers. Malik Brown was a difference maker for the Braves, with 8 catches for 112 yards and a touchdown. Josh Ehrlich passed for 235 yards and rushed for 66. Central State did compete in this game and without those devastating turnovers, things could have turned out differently. 

Carson-Newman 42, No. 4 Kentucky State 14

Carson-Newman’s first drive of the day ended with a punt, but five of the next six drives resulted in touchdowns. Kentucky State stayed in it through the halftime break, trailing 21-14, but the Eagles opened the third quarter with back-to-back scoring drives that put the game out of reach. The Eagles averaged 7.7 yards per rush and put up 453 total yards - all of it on the ground. Joshua Adams and Don Bradley did the bulk of the damage in the run game. An unknown player named No data available in table led the Carson-Newman passing stats. 

Super Region Two Second Round Matchups

Carson-Newman at No. 2 Valdosta State

Newberry at UNC Pembroke 

Super Region One

No. 1 Slippery Rock 59, Charleston 21

I mentioned that a handful of games were actually more competitive than final scores may indicate. In this case, the game was actually more lopsided than the score. Charleston got off the mat and scored three times in the final period but it was 52-0 when they got their first points of the day. The Eagles had 352 yards of total offense and 215 of that came in their final three drives in the fourth quarter. The Rock stormed out to a 38-0 halftime lead and then brought it home from there. DaOne Owens was a tidy 18-27 for 263 yards and score. John Sabo was his top target, netting 128 yards and a TD from 8 grabs, JayJay Jordan carried just 16 times but put up 125 yards and three rushing touchdowns. 

No. 2 Kutztown 34, Fayetteville State 13

Kutztown rushed for 226 yards and quarterback Judd Novak tossed the 100th touchdown pass of his career in the Golden Bears’ first round win. Kutztown would have liked to finish a few more drives in the end zone, but they only punted once and six of eight drives resulted in points. Fayetteville State made a few things happen in this game. The defense came up with a turnover and forced two FG instead of allowing TDs. Jamir Dismukes was efficient (19-26 for 173 and a TD) but they needed more from the run game 

No. 3 East Stroudsburg 24, Assumption 3 

East Stroudsburg earned the program’s first playoff win since 2005 with a victory over Northeast 10 champion Assumption. By the end, it was a 21-point margin but this was close most of the way. The game was scoreless at the end of the first quarter. ESU got the board twice in the second quarter to build a 10-0 lead. It would remain that way until the Warriors added two touchdowns in the final three minutes of the game. The Warriors rushed for 362 yards, with Matt Frame and Harrison Susi both eclipsing the century mark. Archie Jones played well in his second start as Assumption’s quarterback but was intercepted twice. 

California 31, Virginia Union 14

Things didn’t look great for visiting California at the halftime break. The Vulcans did reach the endzone once but their bes drive of the day came up empty. A Virginia Union touchdown on a fourth day play with under a minute left in the first half gave the home team a 14-7 lead. It was only a one score game, but that play felt like a back breaker. The Vulcans stayed patient and chipped into the lead with a field goal  to open the third quarter. After that, the defense started creating opportunities and the offense came to life to take advantage. After Cal reduced the lead to 14-13, the next three Virginia Union drives ended in turnovers. The Vulcans turned those into 21 points. Virginia Union QB RJ Rosales was a late scratch and did not play in the game. That obviously hurt, but the Panthers need to run the ball to win and Cal only allowed 103 yards on the ground. 

Super Region One Second Round Matchups

California at No.1 Slippery Rock

No. 3 East Stroudsburg at No. 2 Kutztown

We will do a deeper dive on the action Sunday night on Inside D2Football and you the regional playoff shows will air on Monday and Tuesday this week. 

Chuck Bitner is the long-time national columnist for D2Football.com and host of Inside D2Football. Questions or comments for Chuck can be sent to [email protected]